The Smith Sisters: Murdered Anonymously

two little girlsA boy named John Smith who was very fond of scary emails and pop-ups. Every day, he would find new ones and post them to everyone he knew. He even started making some himself and sending them to strangers. He loved to scare people on the Net.

John lived in Plainfield, Wisconsin. One day in November 2007, he opened up his Inbox and found a message that appeared to be from two young girls. They called themselves the Smith Sisters and told him they were his older sisters, which confused him because he was an only child. They said years ago, they had lived in his house.

He replied, saying he didnt have any sisters and told them to get lost and leave him alone. The next day, he received a chilling message with some photo attachments. The first photo was of two young girls.
The caption on it said “Smith Sisters murdered anonymously“.

The girls said in the email that they were indeed his older sisters. They told him that in 1993 they had lived in his house. His bedroom had once been their bedroom. They told him all about growing up and about their lives and how happy they had been until one horrible night.

He opened up the other attachment. It was a scan of an old newspaper article.

In 1993, two sisters were brutally murdered in the small-town community of Plainfield, Wisconsin. Lisa Smith, 19 and her sister, Sarah Smith, 15 were attacked in their parents home on the night of November 17th, around 1:30AM. The Smith Sisters were lying in bed when a crazed killer broke into the house. No-one heard them scream. In the morning, their parents found the dead bodies of the Smith Sisters hidden in the bedroom closet. They had been skinned alive. The killer was long gone and no trace of him could be found. They had been murdered anonymously. Police conducted an extensive investigation, but to no avail. The motives for the attack were never discovered. Nor was the attacker ever found. The only lead authorities had was a series of strange emails found in Lisas computer. The case was closed in October of 2000.
In the rest of the email, the sisters said that they were angry that the case was closed and people forgot about them.

They were angry that their parents wanted to forget about them too.

They were angry that their parents decided to start over and had a new baby. A little boy named John.

They were angry that their parents had never mentioned their daughters or their tragic murder to their new son John.

John Smith, sent an angry reply saying he didnt believe what they were saying. He didnt believe the Smith Sisters were really related to him and he didnt believe the newspaper article was real. He told them to go to hell.

Five minutes later, he got another email from them. It said If you dont believe us, look in the bedroom closet.

That was the last email that was found on Johns computer. Police were unable to trace who had sent the messages to him.

On the floor of the closet, the police found a faint message, carved in the wood. It simply read Lisa and Sarah – 1993″. Underneath that, was another carving that read John 2007.

No-one knows what John did next, but in the morning, Johns parents woke up to find their son missing. Then they checked his bedroom closet and got the shock of their lives. There they found the dead body of their son. He had been skinned alive.

No-one knows what really happened that night. Police were only able to piece together parts of the story based on what they found on Johns computer.

The parents were devastated. How could this happen to a family. First their daughters were murdered. And now years later their son is murdered.

It seemed too weird to be just a coincidence. Two sisters are murdered and then years later, their brother is murdered in exactly the same way, in exactly the same place. And the only evidence left behind is a few scary emails Makes you wonder.

Miranda Savanah from Okinawa

The Smith Sisters Murdered Anonymously Video

You may also like...

124 Responses

  1. BLT says:

    Ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww………….Am i the only one who finds getting skinned alive Grody? Grody to the max, perhaps?

  2. Bii says:

    ewwwwwwwwww…. thats gross.. Grody, if you say.

  3. Carilyn says:

    part of this story is actually true, lisa was skinned n hung but sarah was stabbed. if u read any story that says they were both skinned is wrong. but it is grody nonetheless..

    • IMAK9 says:

      Well, Most Urban legends are not true. so… yeah

    • Jelilat says:

      That is true. Urban legends are legends their not really true. They are made to scvare you but good story. But sad and gross.

    • katie says:

      it’s not real it’s so true well >don’t belive anything your told< well can we be friends? PLEASE TALK TO ME AS SOON AS YOU CAN?

  4. zara+monnica says:

    omg… we live in south Africa n we freeked owt. pluss ppl dnt post this nonsens on the web… i mean if u wer murdered how wuld u feel if some1 told sum1 else, n that sum1 twisted the story. i prmise u not the hole thing is true!!!!

  5. ark angel says:

    this is intregeing there was acctualy a case like this but the father and mother were murdered not the so the reason is because they were bitter trying to start a new

  6. SlimShady says:

    cool. they got skinned

  7. tori says:

    that was really scary! you think that was real

  8. Anonymous says:

    Well, that sucks. Why would the sisters need to kill their dear baby bro?

  9. COLE says:

    its not true, yahoo mail was not yet invented that time.

  10. Jessica says:

    The-the tags…they always the same THE SIZE CHANGES… Derp.

  11. Angie says:

    thats really good, but i hardly believe its real :)

  12. tejaswi says:

    its a wonderful and scary too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  13. anna says:

    it’s so sad I’m afraid, is it really all happens? I live in Germany, I hope that does not happen to me

  14. ILMF11 says:

    i told the story to my kids. my little monster was so scared he started crying. and my little prinncess was cracking up.

  15. kittycat22 says:

    i wish that i could watch the video and also thats a stupid chane letter

  16. Anonymous says:

    fake. if someone skinned your children alive in your house, you would’ve moved out of it. you wouldn’t have lived in it and have another child to remind you of the 2 you had skinned alive and have him sleep in that same room.

    • ohms says:

      Not to mention that, it’s also impossible for their parents to not hear any scream from their daughters that were skinning alive.

      If they were stabbed to dead and skinned, that’s possible. But it hard to believe that someone can skin people alive without making any sound.

  17. casanova says:

    maybe it was the killer who pretended to be his sisters and sent him those emails.

    • Stephanie says:

      you are most likely right but its an urban legend

    • gemma says:

      true that but the stories are only scary at night
      i have had nightmares about slender man,
      humans can lick too
      +kuchisake-onna+
      farmer john’s meat packing plant

      don’t get a fright please read all of these thank

  18. Sarah Smith says:

    Omg! im too scared to go to sleep now!!! i have a closet!!! omg omg omg *prays to god that they wont get me*

  19. marya says:

    its so sad just loved this story but i hardly belive its true

  20. Charlee says:

    If my “sisters” went after me i’d last a little bit.

  21. JadeWinchester says:

    this isn’t gross…(or “grody” for that matter)

  22. Anonymous says:

    eeeeeewwwwwwww

  23. Yvonne says:

    I was so distracted by the nonsense phrase “murdered annonomously” while reading this story.

  24. luvinhimhoneylove says:

    wow! i feel sorry about this i dont even know what to say

  25. hopeyoufindthemurderer says:

    thats a shocking story that really makes you scared of what could happen to u!!! mwaaahhhaaaa

  26. Ryan says:

    I drove through plainfield yesterday. Creepy. I live about 20 minutes away from there.

  27. What if the sisters murdered John?!?!

  28. vampiress says:

    lets hope they never come after you lol haha

  29. gemma says:

    >hey they are coming to get you
    please answer me as soon as midnight or you are dead tonight<
    i'm coming you better run to heaven as fast as you can……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

  30. the smith sisters says:

    we will come after anyone who reads this and forgets about us

  31. slender man says:

    i’m coming to get you,
    do not try to hide,
    do not try to run,
    i will hunt you down,
    and murder you,
    i know were you at the moment

  32. the smith sisters says:

    this is not true, we are alive and well and my lil bro is in high school, the story you are saying is about the tale my sister made up….

  33. vampiress says:

    stupid vampires are not real

  34. yianna says:

    i have seen the story of the sisters but not the part about their bother

  35. EMO CHICK says:

    I READ ABOUT IT ND I FORGET ABOUT IT

  36. Clueless says:

    all this from e-mails?
    No.

    Anonymously? obvious no. No unknown force can kill anything. SOme living thing would have had to attack the sisters and John. The skinned alive part? duh, fingerprints are harder to be traced from liquid. The killer was just careful not to let their blood stain the carpet, or be seen. And there’s always the latex-glove fact. Or rubbing your fingerprints off.

    This was simply a series of murders that happened to the same family, most likely a planned event organized by a group of people with a sick and twisted sense of humor.

    If it’s even real.

  37. dark angel says:

    if this is even true you should have more respect twords the dead erase this publishment and let them rest in peace

  38. chloe says:

    hi katie please talk to me soon thanks gemma=chloe

  39. This is all wrong…………………

  40. chloe says:

    HOW? DO YOU WANT TO BE BEST ONLINE BUDDIES? PLEASE ANSWER SOON OR WE WILL NOT BE BUDDIES PLEASE? DO YOU LIKE HORSES? IF YOU DO I WILL BE BEST FRIEND FOREVER THANKS

  41. Lisa Smith says:

    This is true, and it is a proven fact that spirits can interfere with technology, like sending emails for instance.

  42. Sarah Smith says:

    Lisa, stop surfing the web! Mom is in labor. We have to kill the baby, then Dad, then Mom, how dare they forget about us!

  43. John Smith says:

    I HATE YOU LISA AND SARAH! GO BURN IN HELL!

  44. Lisa Smith says:

    Baby is dead, Julie Smith will be arriving…

  45. Julie Smith says:

    Lisa, Sarah, John, WHY DID YOU DO THAT?! I’M NOT EVEN FIVE MINUTES OLD AND YOU HAVE TO MURDER!!

  46. John Smith says:

    IT WASN’T ME! THEY SKINNED ME ALIVE, JUST LIKE YOU! THEY ARE PURE EVIL!!!

  47. Sarah Smith says:

    I HATE YOU LISA! YOU ARE THE ONE WHO WAS SKINNED, THEN YOU SKINNED ME SO I WOULDN’T TOUCH YOUR TOYS! ARGH!

  48. Madison says:

    It is so true how would you make that up it is do tragic

  49. Lisa Smith says:

    AUGH! *sulks* FINE! I. AM. SO-SO-sor-so – sor *chokes*

    I CAN’T DO IT! IT’S YOUR FAULT AS MUCH AS MINE, SARAH! IF YOU DIDN’T OPEN THE WINDOW WHEN ‘SHE’ KNOCKED, ‘SHE’ WOULDN’T HAVE SKINNED ME, I WOULDN’T HAVE SKINNED YOU, YOU WOULDN’T HAVE SKINNED JOHNNY, AND WE WOULDN’T HAVE TO DO AWAY WITH BABY JULIE!

    This is all YOUR fault,Miss Sara Smith, my dear little sister!

  50. Shandril says:

    I just find it funny that this just happens to be in Plainfield where our local Wisconsin serial killer Ed Gein happened to of lived. Grated years apart, still find it ironic.

  51. I'm so EMO says:

    thats so sad how the boy didn’t believe i would of asked questions like what are my parents names and does my mom or dad have a brother or sister.

  52. d says:

    eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedadae

  53. Sarah Smith says:

    Sorry btw that last one wasn’t me me and my friend were at a sleepover and did that

  54. Mudkip lieks you says:

    Wow. I feel soooooo sorry about this ._. I hate serial killers & why the heck would these ghosts wanna comment on this?!

    • Tukaido Inagi says:

      i wanna cry about this… So sad. What really confuses me is the fact that the parents never fcking told their son about this. Seriously.

  55. Anonymous says:

    Wowzers well sux to suk

  56. Courtnee says:

    I feel very sad now

  57. I'm so EMO says:

    such a upsetting story….

  58. bob says:

    Is that true cool that is cool I love horror movies and shows and games and real based events

  59. LonelyInsanity says:

    So depressing and sad… What a tragic story…

  60. Anonymous says:

    How could this be true? Why would any parent especially if they were trying to forget would leave the same closet in their son’s room that his sisters had been killed and skinned alive in? Also if two dead bodies were found in a closet the police would have put it through an extensive search so they would have easily found the carving at the bottom.

  61. Sarah says:

    That is so sad a family dying who was this skinner aughhhh

  62. Kelsey says:

    I think it was the parents… O.O

  63. molly bolton says:

    Thats so scary

  64. Samriddha says:

    really a sensitive story…………bt wat bites me is tht y did the sisters kill their bro?if they wanted 2 take revenge thn they cud hv killed the parents.they knw who hd murdered thn so they cud hv killed the murderer in the sme manner.nd hw cum the police did nt strt tracking the source frm where the msgs came frm?

  65. NOOO!!!!!!!! says:

    this is all fack can you not see this!

  66. Anonymous says:

    Wow.. Yeah definitely do not read this at 1:30am. Worst mistake of my life so far.

  67. The Wasberg Sisters says:

    Jacob we are your sisters want to come and play

  68. Diamond Dude says:

    You know jacob wow you really think id believe this????? what the heck

  69. The Wasberg Sisters says:

    We know your in cross country and in McCool Just so you know Im rasean Jacobs

  70. Noah says:

    I live in Wisconsin lol

  71. Anonymous says:

    It’s not true

  72. leda says:

    Ed Gein is from plainfield wisconsin and i live 22 minutes from plainfield

  73. Ewwww says:

    That is as Grody as ANY THING IVE EVER HEARD OF!

Leave a Reply